West Virginia-1864, Rep

majority 12,714; 1868, Rep. majority 8,869; 1872, Rep. majority 2,264; 1876, Dem. majority 12,384; 1880, Dem. majority 2,069; 1884, Dem. plurality 4,221; 1888, Dem. plurality 839; 1892, Dem. plurality 4,183.